Dughia village is idyllic, but the lives of many of the women who spend their days among its mango orchards, duck ponds and brilliant green paddy fields are anything but. For them, the beauty of the village has been a backdrop to decades of suffering.
They fight back tears to explain how they are lucky to eat once a day and cannot even afford blouses to wear under their tattered saris. All are illiterate, and several have been parted from their children — who have died, gone to faraway cities or been taken in by other families when the cost of raising them at home proved too much.
“I don’t want to think about my life. It’s a very hard story — even listening to it will make you cry,” says Lalita, who spent 16 years separated from her children, doing back-breaking manual labor to pay off US$505)in loans. “My husband got sick, and when he died I was drowning in debt, so I went away to look for work.”
Illustration: Mountain People
Although she travelled barely 100km, wages were so meager she could not afford to return home for more than a decade, and when she did her son and daughter were strangers.
Yet, says aid worker Sagarika Indu, in two years’ time the ageing widow and a handful of other women gathered around her, also living without hope or self-confidence, will probably be secure.
They will have modest savings, valuable assets in the form of a cow and some chickens, and be respected by fellow villagers, perhaps courted by the relatives who once cast them aside as paupers.
Indu is confident about this extraordinary transformation because she will be its agent, as head of a rigorously tested project that she has personally seen change thousands of lives.
“In Bangladesh we reach 90,000 families a year,” she says of the scheme, which was created more than a decade ago by huge national aid organization BRAC, Indu’s employer.
It has also now been exported to 10 other countries.
It is often described as a “poverty graduation” scheme, because it offers not just a financial lifeline out of destitution, but education in the confidence and skills to maintain newfound prosperity, from basic literacy to animal care.
After two years, the “graduates” can support themselves and their families without further aid, and the team that assisted them can move on to helping others. In Bangladesh alone more than 1.7 million households have been transformed.
Supporting people to move out of extreme poverty long-term, rather than just providing food, medicine or cash as temporary relief, is a notoriously stubborn challenge, so the “poverty graduation” model has been analyzed extensively by academics from the London School of Economics (LSE), Yale and other leading universities.
They have confirmed that a one-off intervention can permanently end the most crippling destitution, with benefits that multiply over time — making it a kind of holy grail of aid projects.
“The [Targeting Ultra Poverty, or TUP] program sets beneficiaries on a sustainable path out of poverty,” said the authors of the LSE report, which included seven-year follow-up checks on women who were once enrolled in the program.
They looked at projects around the world to evaluate whether the model thrived beyond Bangladesh, where BRAC can tap into a strong network of services and staff to support the scheme, and found it was still effective in most places.
Charities and governments are often now as keen as bankers to see “return on investment,” although their goal is better lives rather than more profits, and so they are inspired by the experience of women like Rezia Begum, whose village is a short drive from Dughia.
The 35-year-old mother of six lost her parents at eight, and went hungry and homeless for nearly two decades, until she enrolled in the “poverty graduation” program.
“I would see people feeding their children bananas, good food, but never taste it. They would just shout at me to stop staring,” she remembers.
Married by the Karli village community at about 13 to stop her “floating around,” she hoped that would bring an end to destitution — but her husband was equally poor.
“I was half naked when BRAC arrived, I didn’t even have clothes. I would beg people for cast-off saris,” she remembers.
Today she is relaxed and confident, an owner of land and livestock. All her younger children are in school, her elder son is married and she is a dispenser of charity rather than a recipient.
“People invite me to their weddings so I can give gifts,” she says.
The other five women who graduated with her, and are gathered a decade later on a village porch, have also been transformed. Not all have done as well as Begum, but they are independent and financially confident.
Bangladesh has a track record of producing radical ideas to tackle poverty. Its Grameen Bank invented and pioneered micro-credit loans to give the poorest people in society the chance to transform their lives by borrowing money.
The team at BRAC, who have seen the experience of Karli village repeated tens of thousands of times, believe the “poverty graduation” model is one of the most important innovations since then, rigorously tested and tackling one of the most stubborn problems in development.
“It seems to be a good answer to the problem of the ultra-poor,” BRAC vice chair Mushtaque Chowdhury says.
A professor at Columbia University’s School of Public Health, he pioneered the in-house research and evaluation team that allowed BRAC to tweak initial versions of the program and provide the first rigorous evaluations of its success.
He believes the model will be key to the goal of ending the most extreme deprivation within a decade.
“I know no other program that has been followed up for so long, no other trajectory so consistent — not only providing income and occupational changes, but also other benefits, in terms of nutrition and a wider sustained impact, particularly on children,” he says.
Despite the rollout around the world, from Latin America to Africa, and the academic confirmation that the model works, it has not met with universal acclaim, partly because it is relatively expensive.
It provides women with livestock and gives intensive support on caring for themselves, their families and their animals. The regular meetings with a mentor over two years, and the initial gift, together cost hundreds of dollars per family.
The Copenhagen Consensus Center think tank put “graduation” schemes halfway down a list of poverty-reduction projects ranked by their value for money, after commissioning research on the most cost-effective ways to end poverty from BRAC itself.
Near the top of the list was digital access, shifting to e-procurement and digitizing land records, to cut down on corruption, which should bring more than US$600 in rewards for each US$1 spent. By comparison, the graduation model offers a US$2 return for each one paid out, the economists decided.
However, supporters of the program point out that those returns are virtually guaranteed. By contrast, the possible benefits of putting more government functions online were extrapolated from a tiny local project.
“[The graduation model] comes out comparatively badly, with returns of two to one — but at least the benefits are certain. For other projects the evidence is weaker,” The Economist magazine said.
Supporters of the project also point out that it is unusual because of the people it targets, the most deprived and very hardest to reach, whose lives are often too precarious to take advantage of opportunities opened up by mainstream aid projects in areas such as education and healthcare.
“There is a growing realization that the poorest may be being bypassed both by economic growth and by current anti-poverty programs,” said the LSE report, published in July.
Children cannot learn if they are not in school; public hospitals only help those able to reach a doctor or who know that care will be free. Even microfinance projects that have made loans available to millions are out of reach for the very poorest.
“They focused on the economic return, not the confidence improved, the social acceptance, the knowledge improved,” Indu says.
The economists also missed how even marginal economic improvement in dollar terms can completely transform the life of the poorest.
“Most couldn’t eat more than once a day. Now they eat at least two meals, and better food,” Indu says.
The graduation project works because it tackles poverty and social confidence at the same time. Women get an asset — some form of livestock — but also have demands placed on them, and regular mentoring on everything from basic literacy and caring for their animals to visiting government clinics and how to get a micro-loan.
Their children must go to school, they must save, even if it is just a few pennies a month, and they must set aside time to look after their animals, in return for a tiny stipend to cover basic food costs.
A community council helps to rate the village families and choose the most destitute, to avoid corruption and resentment, and protects them as the project gets under way.
“It has actually helped the whole village — every single child here now goes to school,” says Nasammat Salema Khatun, a local politician who organized the selection. “Ten years ago, only perhaps 20 of 100 children in Karli were at school, and the scenario was even worse for the girls.”
She had to broker some disputes, but most neighbors were happy to see people who had gone hungry able to feed themselves.
The biggest problem was a husband with a gambling problem who stole his own family’s cow, hiding it in the house of a conniving neighbor in the middle of the night. He planned to sell it once the search had died down, but the committee found the animal.
“We brought the cow and the husband here, and said to him: ‘If this cow is not safe, we will call [the] police and arrest you as a thief’,” Khatun says with a grin. “That lesson helped.”
Could Asia be on the verge of a new wave of nuclear proliferation? A look back at the early history of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), which recently celebrated its 75th anniversary, illuminates some reasons for concern in the Indo-Pacific today. US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin recently described NATO as “the most powerful and successful alliance in history,” but the organization’s early years were not without challenges. At its inception, the signing of the North Atlantic Treaty marked a sea change in American strategic thinking. The United States had been intent on withdrawing from Europe in the years following
My wife and I spent the week in the interior of Taiwan where Shuyuan spent her childhood. In that town there is a street that functions as an open farmer’s market. Walk along that street, as Shuyuan did yesterday, and it is next to impossible to come home empty-handed. Some mangoes that looked vaguely like others we had seen around here ended up on our table. Shuyuan told how she had bought them from a little old farmer woman from the countryside who said the mangoes were from a very old tree she had on her property. The big surprise
Ursula K. le Guin in The Ones Who Walked Away from Omelas proposed a thought experiment of a utopian city whose existence depended on one child held captive in a dungeon. When taken to extremes, Le Guin suggests, utilitarian logic violates some of our deepest moral intuitions. Even the greatest social goods — peace, harmony and prosperity — are not worth the sacrifice of an innocent person. Former president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁), since leaving office, has lived an odyssey that has brought him to lows like Le Guin’s dungeon. From late 2008 to 2015 he was imprisoned, much of this
The issue of China’s overcapacity has drawn greater global attention recently, with US Secretary of the Treasury Janet Yellen urging Beijing to address its excess production in key industries during her visit to China last week. Meanwhile in Brussels, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen last week said that Europe must have a tough talk with China on its perceived overcapacity and unfair trade practices. The remarks by Yellen and Von der Leyen come as China’s economy is undergoing a painful transition. Beijing is trying to steer the world’s second-largest economy out of a COVID-19 slump, the property crisis and