Turkish Nobel laureate Orhan Pamuk has described the situation in his country as “going from bad to worse and even towards terrible” following the government’s attempts to block access to Twitter, as a phalanx of writers from Zadie Smith to Gunter Grass line up to state their “grave concern” about “the freedom of words” in Turkey today.
The authors, who also include Salman Rushdie, Margaret Atwood, Karl Ove Knausgaard and fellow Nobel laureate of Grass and Pamuk — Elfriede Jelinek, have added their names to a joint letter from PEN International and English PEN.
PEN is a worldwide association of writers. It called the ban on Twitter announced two weeks ago “an unacceptable violation of the right to freedom of speech.”
The Turkish government restricted access to the micro-blogging Web site, and Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan indicated the ban could be extended, saying he would not “leave this nation at the mercy of YouTube and Facebook,” and pledging to “take the necessary steps in the strongest way.”
On Thursday, he appeared to follow up that threat as Turkish media reported that the country’s telecommunications authority had blocked YouTube as a “precautionary administrative measure.”
The latest curbs came hours after an audio recording of a high-level security meeting was leaked on the video-sharing Web site. Turkey previously banned YouTube in 2007, but lifted the ban three years later.
According to PEN, the Twitter ban remains in place despite an administrative court order on Wednesday ordering its suspension pending a court judgement.
Pamuk, who won the Nobel prize for literature in 2006, not long after Turkish state prosecutors had charged him with “insulting Turkishness” for remarks he made to an interviewer, told the Guardian “there were times in Turkey when free speech was equally bad ... as in 2008 when YouTube was closed, but at that time we were at least hopeful about the future. Not now. The situation here is going from bad to worse, and even towards terrible.”
Pamuk’s translator, Maureen Freely, the new president of English PEN, added: “The real worry, I think, is that Erdogan now seems to have the power to do whatever he wishes, whenever he wishes. And that is why we’re so concerned about what he’ll do next, to silence dissenters and crush opposition wherever he sees it.”
The signatories to the letter point to the fact Turkey ranks 154th among 180 countries on the World Press Freedom Index, saying that even today, “translators, editors, publishers, poets and writers face criminal proceedings and even imprisonment for legitimate expression under a variety of legislative fetters.”
PEN particularly highlighted the case of Muharrem Erbey, a human rights lawyer and writer who was arrested in 2009, and who is in prison awaiting trial. PEN believes the charges against the author are politically motivated, and that Erbey is being held because of his alleged affiliation with Kurdish political parties.
In their letter, the writers — from Turkey and around the world — are asking Turkey’s leaders “not to retreat from democracy and its keystone, freedom of speech; but rather to recognize their obligations under international treaties and to lift the block on Twitter.”
“We urge them to remember that this beautiful country will be stronger and happier when, and if, it appreciates pluralism, diversity and the freedom of words,” they write. “We welcome the administrative court in Ankara’s decision to suspend the [Twitter] ban ahead of a full judgment and urge the telecommunications authority to restore access to Twitter immediately.”