Tue, Mar 20, 2012 - Page 9 News List

Apple firestorm leads artist to change his show

Critics worry that off-Broadway performer Mike Daisey’s credibility issues may have set back the fight to improve working conditions in China

By Mark Kennedy  /  AP, NEW YORK

Illustration: Yusha

Mike Daisey, the off-Broadway performer who admitted that he made up parts of his one-man show about Apple products being made in Chinese sweatshops, has cut questionable sections from the monologue and added a prologue explaining the controversy.

Oskar Eustis, artistic director of The Public Theater, where the monologue is being performed, said on Saturday that Daisey has “eliminated anything he doesn’t feel he can stand behind” from the show and added a section at the beginning in which he addresses the questions raised by critics.

Eustis called the prologue “the best possible frame we could give the audience for the controversy” and said Daisey agreed to make the changes himself, which are “his and his alone.”

“Mike is a great storyteller, not a journalist. I wish he had been clearer about that distinction in the making of this piece,” Eustis said after seeing Saturday’s matinee performance. “If we had understood the rules Mike was using to make the show, we would have framed it differently from the outset.”

Daisey portrayed his work as fact during a media blitz to promote his critically acclaimed show, and he misled dozens of news and entertainment outlets, including the popular public radio show This American Life, The Associated Press, the New York Times, MSNBC and HBO’s Real Time with Bill Maher.

However, in an interview with This American Life host Ira Glass broadcast on Friday, Daisey acknowledged that some of the claims in his show, The Agony and the Ecstasy of Steve Jobs, were not true. The show retracted its Jan. 6 episode because Glass said he could not vouch for the truth of its claims.

Daisey, who admitted on Friday on his Web site that the work is a mix of fact and fiction, did not respond to questions sent to his personal e-mail account, and his publicist did not respond to a request for comment on Saturday.

The controversy is unlikely to lessen the media scrutiny of the Chinese factories that make Apple products, since news outlets including the Times have reported about the dangerous working conditions in them, including explosions inside iPad plants where four people were killed and 77 were injured.

However, some of Daisey’s older monologues might get a second look.

“If he had only chosen to actually utilize what theater allows you to do — which is to transform fact into something that retains an emotional truth,” said Howard Sherman, a former executive director of the American Theatre Wing and an arts administrator and producer.

He did not see Daisey’s show, but said he thought it might “call into question people who do this in the future.”

Daisey is just the latest artist to apparently get tripped up by the truth — joining a list that includes James Frey, who admitted that he lied in his memoir A Million Little Pieces, and Greg Mortenson, who is accused of fabricating key parts of his best-selling book Three Cups of Tea.

The controversy raised once again the question of the artist’s role in society and what his or her responsibility is to the truth, and whether Daisey ultimately hurt or harmed the very people he was trying to help.

Terry Teachout, chief theater critic for the Wall Street Journal, called Daisey a talented artist, but said the episode was “unforgivable,” and Peter Marks, the critic for the Washington Post, tweeted that Daisey’s “zeal seems to have gotten the better of his judgment.”

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top