Forty years ago, space engineers launched a probe that would play a pivotal role in changing our understanding of our place in the cosmos. On May 30, 1971, Mariner 9 was dispatched to Mars on an Atlas Centaur rocket and in November that year slipped into orbit around the Red Planet.
In doing so, the US robot spaceship became the first manmade object to be placed in orbit around another planet. Humans had added an artificial satellite to another world. A few days later, two other spacecraft, Mars 2 and Mars 3, both built by the Soviet Union, followed suit and achieved Martian orbit. In three weeks, the Red Planet had become a scientific hotspot.
Thus began a revolution in our understanding of the solar system, a family of planets that space probes have shown to be far stranger and more exotic than expected, with Mars producing the largest number of surprises. Mariner 9 showed it possesses the solar system’s largest mountain and its biggest canyon, while ancient riverbeds and streams were discovered at several sites, findings that have been confirmed and explored in far greater detail by subsequent probes and which continue to maintain hopes that we will one day find signs of life on another world.
Forty years on, Mars is still a place of fascination for humanity, though its investigation has been a rocky business.
“The story of Mars exploration has been a real rollercoaster,” says Fred Taylor, Oxford astronomer and professor, who has worked closely with NASA on a number of missions to the planet.
“Once, it seemed destined to support life. Then we thought it was utterly dead and featureless. Then we discovered — thanks to Mariner 9 — that it had a landscape through which water had poured. After that, craft found its soil contained no signs of biological material. Since then, we have bounced back and are hopeful life may exist deep underground,” he says.
As a result, a swath of missions to Mars is being planned for the next few years with the US, Russia, China and Europe all preparing spacecraft. These will include automated rovers, with one, called ExoMars, that is being built in the UK; craft that drill deep below the planet’s surface; another that will land on Mars’s moon, Phobos, and survey the planet from there; and, ultimately, a robot spaceship that will fire samples of Martian soil and rocks back to Earth for analysis.
“Once we get our hands on that, we will have a real chance of finding out if there is life underneath the Martian surface,” says David Parker, director of space science at the British National Space Centre.
If this flotilla of interplanetary craft succeeds in finding life, the study of Mars will have come full circle. In the years leading up to the space age, it was still hoped that the most closely studied planet in the solar system possessed life. Changes in surface features, which could be seen through ground-based telescopes, were assumed to be caused by seasonal changes in vegetation that were fed by meltwater pouring from the planet’s icecaps. In the 19th and 20th centuries, astronomers, such as Percival Lowell, had even argued that these melt-waters were being channeled through canals built by intelligent beings.
By the mid-20th century, however, few scientists clung to such notions. As telescopes got more and more powerful, Mars seemed less and less hospitable. Nevertheless, those color changes on the surface kept alive some hopes of finding primitive life.
Then the first probes arrived at Mars, with the US succeeding with three missions — Mariner 4 in 1965 and Mariner 6 and Mariner 7 in 1969. These were “fly-by” missions and took only a few dozen photographs and measurements as they flashed past the planet.
From these, Mars looked like the Moon, a dead world. Its surface atmospheric pressure was a pathetic 6 millibars, compared with 1,000 on Earth. There was nothing to breathe or provide protection against the sun’s deadly ultraviolet radiation, from which Earth’s thick atmosphere shields us. The landscape was also plastered with craters.
“It was a low point,” Taylor says. “However, all that changed two years later with Mariner 9, which got us our first proper look at Mars. It was an orbiter and could study the planet for a long time. And yes, parts of it did look like the Moon. But there are also these wonderful mountains, polar caps and valleys as well as dried-up river valleys which showed water had once flown there. Suddenly, Mars looked as if it had a much more Earth-like climate in the past — though we didn’t know if that was the recent past or the distant past. And we still don’t know.”
It is for this reason that Mariner 9 remains of such importance today. It restored hopes of finding life on Mars and revealed a world of surprising variety — though this did not seem so when the spaceship first arrived.
The planet was then engulfed in one of the incredible dust storms that occasionally sweep Mars, covering its entire surface. It looked utterly featureless, until the storm began to subside and the dust settled, revealing a strange sequence of markings at one site.
First, a dark, circular outline emerged, which scientists eventually realized was a volcanic caldera. As the dust dissipated, its outline grew and filled out, revealing a 25,000m peak with a 30km wide caldera in its full craggy glory. This was the solar system’s largest mountain: Olympus Mons.
“If you wanted to build one on Earth, you would have to excavate all of Texas to a depth of 8km for the raw material,” says Oliver Morton in his book Mapping Mars. “An Everest on top of an Everest would not come to the summit of Olympus Mons.”
Then a 4,000km gash was discovered in the side of Mars, Valles Marineris (the Mariner Valley), an immense complex of canyons, more than 6.4km deep and 96.6km across. Crucially, from the eastern end of this great rift valley, Mariner 9 sent back pictures of what appeared to be dried-up river beds connected to the bed of a former ocean.
Almost overnight, the forbidding impression relayed by earlier missions was replaced by a vision of a planet with a water-rich history like the Earth’s and, therefore, a place much more suitable to the development of life.
“The great breakthrough in our understanding of Mars was due to two spacecraft, Mariner 4 and, above all, Mariner 9,” British astronomer Patrick Moore says.
Thanks to the latter, it had been discovered that Mars was a warm, wet place when life arose on Earth. So life could have evolved there, and could still be thriving below the surface, safe from harmful solar ultraviolet radiation and nourished by underground water supplies.
What was needed now were craft that could find those lifeforms, a task that has proved awkward and elusive, but which may soon be resolved, say scientists. The first stab at following Mariner 9 was made when the US embarked on the Viking missions of 1976. These involved two craft being carried to Mars and landed with precision on its surface. Soil was scooped from the surface and analyzed in tiny robot laboratories for evidence of biological activity.
“It was an incredibly expensive undertaking,” Taylor says. “And it was a great success — except that there didn’t appear to be any life. People were very disappointed. They wanted to find life, but they didn’t.”
After that, NASA gave up on Mars for 20 years. Martian studies reached an all-time low until, in 1996, NASA scientists, led by David McKay, announced they had found possible signs of life on a Martian meteorite called ALH84001.
This lump of rock, weighing almost 2kg, fell to Earth 13,000 years ago, after being blasted into space when an asteroid struck Mars. Found in the Allan Hills of Antarctica, it is one of an estimated 100 — out of the 50,000 meteorites that have been found on Earth — that is reckoned to have come from Mars. Their composition of elements is similar to those of Martian rocks, and there are traces of atmospheric gases identical to those found by spacecraft on Mars. Analysis of ALH84001 revealed chemicals that could have been produced by living organisms, as well as rod-shaped structures that looked like terrestrial bacteria, McKay and his colleagues said.
The discovery was promoted as a triumph by NASA. According to then-US president Bill Clinton, it spoke “of the possibility of life.”
The search for life on Mars was back on track, though the announcement was treated with considerable suspicion by some scientists who continue to criticize the NASA team’s analysis and who argue that the features seen on meteorite ALH84001 could just as easily be attributed to inorganic or geological processes. McKay has refused to back down, however.
NASA launched the Mars Pathfinder mission in 1996, landing a tiny robot rover, Sojourner, which trundled round the Martian surface, beaming back pictures of rocks and craters. It was a major PR success and stimulated a renewed wave of Martian investigations which have included some notable successes, such as the larger and more advanced Spirit and Opportunity robot rovers which landed in 2003. Opportunity is still in operation today. Other missions were less successful, however, and have included several noticeable losses.
Several even more advanced missions are also planned with the ultimate aim of returning a sample of Martian soil to Earth, where it can be analyzed for signs of life. A great deal will be learned about the geology, meteorology, soil chemistry and geography of Mars and a vast sum of money spent. The question is: Do those billions represent value for money? It is a difficult one to answer, though we should be clear about the consequences of finding life on Mars, no matter how primitive it turns out to be. They will be considerable.
Consider the two competing scenarios. First, probes discover lifeforms that have a different genetic code from the DNA that is commonplace in life on Earth. That would indicate that Martian life had a very different evolutionary history from ours and would tell us that on two sister planets, in one humble corner of the galaxy, life appeared independently and separately, a fact that would suggest the appearance of life in general is a common affair on worlds elsewhere in the galaxy.
It is extremely unlikely that such a highly specialized, complex molecule like DNA could have evolved separately on the two planets, indicating that there must be a common origin for Martian and Earthly life. And given that it is far easier for rocks carrying cells or bacteria to escape Mars’ relatively low gravitational field compared with Earth’s relatively powerful gravity, we would face an intriguing prospect: Life based on DNA first appeared on Mars and then spread to Earth, where it then evolved into the myriad forms of plants and creatures that exist today. If this was found to be the case, we would have to face the logical conclusion: We are all Martians.
Of course, it may be that we find no evidence at all that life evolved on Mars, no matter how hard we look. Again, the discovery would be illuminating, suggesting that Earth is one of the few outposts that harbor life anywhere in the galaxy and that it is a place that needs special care and attention. Again, we would be wiser for the discovery.
In the next few decades, we should find answers. In the meantime, Mariner 9, the craft that kickstarted our hunt for life on other worlds in our solar system, continues to orbit Mars, a silent, dead craft whose fuel and electricity have been used up — and its work completed.
Milestones in Martian exploration
Mariner 9
Reached orbit on Nov. 13, 1971
The first spaceship to orbit another planet, Mariner 9 transformed our knowledge of Mars. It beamed back information for a year before it ran out of fuel and was switched off on Oct. 27, 1972. Among its discoveries was the great 4,023km rift valley Vallis Mareneris — the Mariner Valley.
Viking 1 and Viking 2
Landed in July and September 1976
These two craft made successful soft landings and ran experiments that included the use of a robot arm to scoop up Martian soil. These samples were tested for the presence of chemicals that might indicate the presence of living organisms. The results were negative.
Phobos-Grunt
Scheduled to launch in November this year
This ambitious international project is the next scheduled Mars mission. The Chinese Yinghuo-1 and Russian Phobos-Grunt will launch from Baikonur in Kazakhstan. Yinghuo-1 will orbit Mars and study its atmosphere while the Russian craft will land on the moon Phobos and attempt to return with a sample of its soil.
Exomars
Launches 2016 and 2018
A double European effort, this would involve launching a lander craft in 2016 and following this up with a rover vehicle, now under construction in the UK, that would explore the landscape in search of signs of living organisms and survey the terrain for future manned missions to the planet.
Mars Sample Return
Launch 2020
This spaceship would be launched by the US and would land on Mars, collect samples of soil excavated by previous robot rovers and then blast it back to Earth, where it could be studied for signs of biological activity.
The curse of Mars — why do half the exploration missions fail?
The exploration of Mars has a shaky record. Of the 38 attempts to send probes to the planet, 19 have ended in failure, consumed by the Great Galactic Ghoul, as astronomers describe the blight that has cursed so many missions. Britain’s Beagle 2, which was lost after it began its descent to the Martian surface on Dec. 25, 2003, has plenty of company among the other bits of wreckage that pepper the Red Planet’s landscape, as Oxford’s professor Fred Taylor knows only too well.
He led the team that built a device for analyzing variations in water vapor, dust and temperature in the planet’s atmosphere called the Mars Climate Sounder. It was launched on the US Mars Observer in 1992.
“Everything was going fine until the engine was fired to put the craft into Mars orbit. It blew up. We never did find out why that happened,” he said.
So Taylor and his team built another sounder — for the Mars Climate Orbiter, which was launched in 1998. This time there was a navigation error, caused by controllers who confused imperial and metric measurements. As a result, the spaceship flew too close to Mars.
“It crashed,” Taylor says. “Our sounder is in pieces on Mars today — which makes it the first British hardware to reach Mars. We got there four years before Beagle 2’s crash.”
Taylor’s Mars Climate Sounder was resurrected a third time and put on the Mars Reconnaissance Observer, which was successfully put into orbit round the planet in March 2006.
“We are now getting lots of lovely data from it,” Taylor says.
“We have recorded the temperature, pressure, humidity, dust and ice clouds from the planet’s surface to an altitude of 50 miles [80.5km] and have uncovered daily and seasonal weather cycles, storms, fronts and other meteorological systems,” he says.
“We have found that the Martian climate has undergone massive changes over time, from conditions that used to be warm and wet, like those on Earth, to the ice age that now permanently grips the planet,” he says.
Saudi Arabian largesse is flooding Egypt’s cultural scene, but the reception is mixed. Some welcome new “cooperation” between two regional powerhouses, while others fear a hostile takeover by Riyadh. In Cairo, historically the cultural capital of the Arab world, Egyptian Minister of Culture Nevine al-Kilany recently hosted Saudi Arabian General Entertainment Authority chairman Turki al-Sheikh. The deep-pocketed al-Sheikh has emerged as a Medici-like patron for Egypt’s cultural elite, courted by Cairo’s top talent to produce a slew of forthcoming films. A new three-way agreement between al-Sheikh, Kilany and United Media Services — a multi-media conglomerate linked to state intelligence that owns much of
The US and other countries should take concrete steps to confront the threats from Beijing to avoid war, US Representative Mario Diaz-Balart said in an interview with Voice of America on March 13. The US should use “every diplomatic economic tool at our disposal to treat China as what it is... to avoid war,” Diaz-Balart said. Giving an example of what the US could do, he said that it has to be more aggressive in its military sales to Taiwan. Actions by cross-party US lawmakers in the past few years such as meeting with Taiwanese officials in Washington and Taipei, and
The Republic of China (ROC) on Taiwan has no official diplomatic allies in the EU. With the exception of the Vatican, it has no official allies in Europe at all. This does not prevent the ROC — Taiwan — from having close relations with EU member states and other European countries. The exact nature of the relationship does bear revisiting, if only to clarify what is a very complicated and sensitive idea, the details of which leave considerable room for misunderstanding, misrepresentation and disagreement. Only this week, President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) received members of the European Parliament’s Delegation for Relations
Denmark’s “one China” policy more and more resembles Beijing’s “one China” principle. At least, this is how things appear. In recent interactions with the Danish state, such as applying for residency permits, a Taiwanese’s nationality would be listed as “China.” That designation occurs for a Taiwanese student coming to Denmark or a Danish citizen arriving in Denmark with, for example, their Taiwanese partner. Details of this were published on Sunday in an article in the Danish daily Berlingske written by Alexander Sjoberg and Tobias Reinwald. The pretext for this new practice is that Denmark does not recognize Taiwan as a state under