Sun, Dec 19, 2004 - Page 9 News List

Gay activists forced to seek renewed strategy in the US

While some local and state laws in the US have allowed same-sex marriages, political conservatives have capitalized on 'the gay issue' to win elections, roll back the debate - and overturn laws

AP , WASHINGTON

ILLUSTRATION: YENTSUN CHOU

The ritual was replayed from Boston to San Francisco: Exuberant gay couples sharing marriage vows and slices of wedding cake.

After decades of seeking the same basic rights as most Americans, gay activists celebrated a long-sought achievement as the highest court in Massachusetts ruled that same-sex marriage was legal. In San Francisco, Mayor Gavin Newsom performed gay marriages even though he had no similar court affirmation.

Gays thought barriers were finally crumbling. Then came the elections.

Outraged by these images of gay couples, conservatives clamored for laws not only banning gay marriage but in some states for prohibiting civil unions and domestic partnerships. Nine of the 13 states that acted on or before Election Day on laws barring gay marriage also banned other forms of recognition for same-sex relationships.

Effects of those measures are already being felt. Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm, a Democrat, will remove same-sex partner benefits from contracts negotiated with state workers after the voter-approved amendment to the Michigan Constitution that bans gay marriage "and similar unions."

Granholm has said she'll go ahead with the benefits if a court says they're allowable under the constitutional amendment.

The lack of activists' success in the United States stands in contrast to Canada where the Supreme Court ruled Thursday that gay marriage was constitutional, allowing the government there to call on Parliament to legalize same-sex unions nationwide.

The string of U.S. election defeats -- and the extent of the restrictions -- has forced gay activists to reassess their strategy in what they see as a protracted fight for equal rights.

"There now is a profound realization that this struggle is going to go on for a very long time," said Matthew Foreman, executive director of the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force.

"People understand the reality of that in a way they did not before," he said

Suggestions that gays would move more cautiously or bargain for certain rights prompted letters from activists to all members of Congress saying there would be no retreat in their push for equal rights or trading of gay rights for support of other measures -- like changes in Social Security.

While many gays heralded the ruling in Massachusetts, several said they had mixed feelings as they watched the unprecedented developments.

"I thought what was done in Massachusetts was worth the price," Democratic Representative Barney Frank said of the legal success of gay couples who sued for the right to get married.

"The mistake was in San Francisco," said Frank, an openly gay congressman. Newsom's short-lived effort to allow gay marriages was "a lot of hoopla that didn't accomplish anything," Frank said.

Gay activists say their strategy will include:

-- Seeking public support for equal protection for gays and taking that message to the conservative-leaning states in the South and West won by President Bush. Activists say there are many in those states who would be sympathetic to the difficulties gays face if they had more information about the legal barriers -- both in the workplace and in recognition of relationships.

-- Answering the high-profile religious leaders who are opposed to gay rights with religious leaders who are supportive.

-- Shifting resources to work with corporate leaders about the need for more protections for gays in the workplace.

This story has been viewed 3465 times.
TOP top