Arthur Andersen LLP said in an internal memorandum that the firm's policy on handling documents was so imprecise it may have led to shredding of Enron Corp records now at the heart of the auditor's indictment.
The Chicago-based firm's memo was sent to Andersen partners on Thursday, the same day the firm's indictment for obstruction of justice was announced by the Justice Department. The memo was intended for briefing clients on why they should stay with the accounting firm, said a person familiar with the matter. Legal experts say the memo may hurt Andersen's legal defense.
Andersen's "document policy, with its lack of clarity and ambiguities, played a key role in the destruction of Enron-related documents that occurred in the fall of 2001," the firm said in the 14-page memo, obtained by Bloomberg News.
PHOTO: AFP
The indictment said Andersen, Enron's auditor, destroyed "tons" of material at four offices after the firm was alerted on Oct. 19 that the Securities and Exchange Commission was looking into Enron. The energy trader collapsed and declared bankruptcy on Dec. 2 amid accusations it distorted its financial record-keeping.
Andersen's memo said the vagueness of the document-retention policy may have contributed to misinterpretation of an e-mail sent by in-house attorney Nancy Temple at the Chicago headquarters.
On Oct. 12, as Andersen's Houston office was discovering inaccuracies in Enron's accounting, Temple joined in the review and inserted language calling the accounting on Enron's Raptor partnerships "inappropriate," the memo said.
Forty minutes later, Temple sent an e-mail to Michael Odom, a senior partner in Houston, reminding him of the document policy, the memo said. Odom forwarded the message to David Duncan, lead partner on the Enron audit who may have interpreted it as instructions to shred documents, Andersen's 14-page memo said.
Andersen's policy calls for storing essential work papers in a central file after an audit. Everything else -- drafts, internal memos and the like -- are to be destroyed as soon as they become "expendable," the memo said.
"There was no clear guidance" when litigation was pending as to "what obligations existed if Andersen was not a party to, but was only a witness in, litigation or government investigation," the memo said.
Temple and Odom didn't return phone calls today.
Admitting a lack of clarity may undercut Andersen's defense that senior officials didn't authorize the shredding by employees in Houston, said Robert Plotkin, a white-collar defense lawyer with Paul Hastings Janofsky & Walker in Washington. Companies typically must show that employees were acting outside the scope of their jobs to defeat criminal charges, he said.
"You have to show that people were acting contrary to clear corporate policies," Plotkin said.
At the time of the Enron investigation, Andersen was under a legal order not to commit any wrongdoing -- part of a settlement with the SEC last June of a landmark case involving Waste Management Inc, the biggest US trash hauler.
Andersen agreed to a US$7 million fine -- then the SEC's biggest against an accounting firm -- and paid US$20 million to settle investor lawsuits alleging the firm issued misleading audits. Andersen also previously paid US$110 million Andersen to settle similar claims by investors in appliance maker Sunbeam Corp.
In both cases, the SEC had access to Andersen's work papers, possibly leading to the firm's new document policy, first communicated to employees in May 2000.
When Odom spoke to accountants about the document policy on Oct. 10, he "explained to the group that in several recent lawsuits Andersen had had to produce documents that should not have been retained and that it was `embarrassing and extra work' for Andersen to be retaining any materials not required for the central files," the Andersen memo said.
"Odom then explained the policy does not permit document destruction when litigation is pending," the memo said. "But that if documents are destroyed and `litigation is filed the next day, that's great ... because ... we followed our own policy. And whatever there was that might have been of interest to somebody is gone and is irretrievable.'" On Oct. 12, Temple's e-mail reminded the audit team that it "will be helpful to make sure that we have complied with the policy," the memo said.
On Oct. 23, after the SEC made initial contacts with Enron, Duncan called staff meetings in Houston about the document policy, the memo said. Contemporaneous notes show that one meeting included "the directive `clean up -- documentation' followed by the explanation `SEC voluntary request/two suits filed, more on way,'" the memo said.
"It is possible," the memo said, "that Duncan still had this [Temple] e-mail in mind when he met with his audit staff 11 days later and urged them to take action to come into compliance with the firm's policy." Destruction of Enron documents intensified on that day, Oct. 23, with the shredding of 26 trunks of records and 24 boxes during the week, the memo said. The shredding continued the following week, although at a slower rate, and didn't stop until Nov. 8 when the SEC subpoenaed Andersen records.
In its rebuttal to the indictment, Andersen said staff in Houston shredded documents without approval from headquarters.
In testimony before a House committee in January, Temple denied she intended to prompt shredding of Enron records. "I did not instruct Mr. Duncan to shred documents," Temple said. She said she told Duncan's team "to retain the relevant documents."
The government is aiming to recruit 1,096 foreign English teachers and teaching assistants this year, the Ministry of Education said yesterday. The foreign teachers would work closely with elementary and junior-high instructors to create and teach courses, ministry official Tsai Yi-ching (蔡宜靜) said. Together, they would create an immersive language environment, helping to motivate students while enhancing the skills of local teachers, she said. The ministry has since 2021 been recruiting foreign teachers through the Taiwan Foreign English Teacher Program, which offers placement, salary, housing and other benefits to eligible foreign teachers. Two centers serving northern and southern Taiwan assist in recruiting and training
WIDE NET: Health officials said they are considering all possibilities, such as bongkrekic acid, while the city mayor said they have not ruled out the possibility of a malicious act of poisoning Two people who dined at a restaurant in Taipei’s Far Eastern Department Store Xinyi A13 last week have died, while four are in intensive care, the Taipei Department of Health said yesterday. All of the outlets of Malaysian vegetarian restaurant franchise Polam Kopitiam have been ordered to close pending an investigation after 11 people became ill due to suspected food poisoning, city officials told a news conference in Taipei. The first fatality, a 39-year-old man who ate at the restaurant on Friday last week, died of kidney failure two days later at the city’s Mackay Memorial Hospital. A 66-year-old man who dined
EYE ON STRAIT: The US spending bill ‘doubles security cooperation funding for Taiwan,’ while also seeking to counter the influence of China US President Joe Biden on Saturday signed into law a US$1.2 trillion spending package that includes US$300 million in foreign military financing to Taiwan, as well as funding for Taipei-Washington cooperative projects. The US Congress early on Saturday overwhelmingly passed the Further Consolidated Appropriations Act 2024 to avoid a partial shutdown and fund the government through September for a fiscal year that began six months ago. Under the package, the Defense Appropriations Act would provide a US$27 billion increase from the previous fiscal year to fund “critical national defense efforts, including countering the PRC [People’s Republic of China],” according to a summary
‘CARRIER KILLERS’: The Tuo Chiang-class corvettes’ stealth capability means they have a radar cross-section as small as the size of a fishing boat, an analyst said President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) yesterday presided over a ceremony at Yilan County’s Suao Harbor (蘇澳港), where the navy took delivery of two indigenous Tuo Chiang-class corvettes. The corvettes, An Chiang (安江) and Wan Chiang (萬江), along with the introduction of the coast guard’s third and fourth 4,000-tonne cutters earlier this month, are a testament to Taiwan’s shipbuilding capability and signify the nation’s resolve to defend democracy and freedom, Tsai said. The vessels are also the last two of six Tuo Chiang-class corvettes ordered from Lungteh Shipbuilding Co (龍德造船) by the navy, Tsai said. The first Tuo Chiang-class vessel delivered was Ta Chiang (塔江)