US complains over India solar program

DISCRIMINATION?:Relations between the two nations are being tested again as the US says India did not address its concerns over solar-installation supply rules


Wed, Feb 12, 2014 - Page 15

The US brought a trade complaint against India on Monday over a solar energy program it says discriminates against US manufacturers, adding another wrinkle to a bilateral relationship strained by the recent arrest and strip-search of an Indian diplomat.

It is the second time in a year that Washington has requested dispute settlement consultations with India over the program that it contends violates WTO rules by requiring that suppliers use Indian-manufactured solar cells and modules.

US officials say the trade case was in the works long before the arrest in December last year of then-Indian deputy consul-general Devyani Khobragade, who was accused of visa fraud and under-paying her maid. In a compromise, Khobragade was indicted then deported last month, and both governments say they want to repair the relationship.

In announcing the trade complaint, US Trade Representative Michael Froman said US President Barack Obama’s administration was “standing up” for the rights of US workers and businesses — a common theme in a year of congressional elections, and as the administration tries to persuade fellow Democrats to support its agenda to expand trade in Asia.

US officials say India is the second-largest foreign market for the US solar energy industry after Japan, with exports totaling US$119 million before the local content requirements were introduced in 2011 and having fallen since then.

The South Asian nation is looking to increase its use of solar power 20-fold by 2020 under its so-called National Solar Mission.

In February last year, the US held dispute consultations with India over the first phase of that program, but the US says its concerns were not addressed. It is now seeking fresh consultations over the program’s second phase, approved by India’s Cabinet in October last year, that has been expanded to include thin film technology which comprises the majority of US solar product exports to India.

“These types of ‘localization’ measures not only are an unfair barrier to US exports, but also raise the cost of solar energy, hindering deployment of solar energy around the world, including in India,” Froman said at a news conference.

A request for consultations is the first step in the WTO dispute settlement process. If the matter is not resolved through consultations within 60 days of the request, the US may ask the WTO to establish a dispute settlement panel and seek redress.

US trade officials said the consultation request is a serious step to take, but dismissed suggestions of a trade war between the two nations, saying it is part of a “mature” trading relationship.

Trade in goods and services between the two nations has risen sharply in the past decade to about US$100 billion annually, and diplomatic and security ties have also deepened.

However, US businesses complain over continuing market barriers.

India has its own complaints, including over visa policies for high-skilled Indian workers.