Morgan Stanley fined over Facebook IPO

OVER AND DONE::Although the firm did not admit guilt, it agreed to be censured and pay the fine, and was pleased to put the matter behind it, a company spokesperson said


Wed, Dec 19, 2012 - Page 15

Morgan Stanley, the lead underwriter for Facebook’s troubled public stock offering (IPO), has agreed to pay US$5 million to Massachusetts’ securities regulators after they accused it of disclosing a revenue shortfall only to certain analysts and not the general public.

According to state regulators, a Morgan Stanley banker organized phone calls between Facebook’s treasurer and the analysts of major underwriters to relay revenue figures that were not included in revised documents Facebook Inc filed with US securities authorities on May 9, about a week before the IPO of stock.

The numbers were lower than what many analysts had expected and caused them to revise their annual revenue estimates down about 3 percent below the US$5 billion that Facebook had earlier forecast for this year, according to Massachusetts officials.

The renewed estimates were available to investment banks, but not individual investors who bought into one of the most highly anticipated IPO of stock in history.

“Main Street investors were put at a significant disadvantage to Wall Street,” Massachusetts’ Secretary of the Commonwealth, William Galvin, said in a press release on Monday.

Facebook shares were priced at US$38, the top of a projected range, but finished the first day of exuberant trading barely above its initial public offering price, at US$38.23.

Since then, shares have failed to return to that lofty valuation. On Monday, they closed down US$0.03 at US$26.78, about 30 percent below the IPO price.

Morgan Stanley did not admit guilt, but agreed to be censured and pay the fine.

Spokesman Wesley McDade said in a statement that the company was pleased “to have put this matter behind us.”

“Morgan Stanley is committed to robust compliance with both the letter and the spirit of all applicable regulations and laws,” he said.

In October, Massachusetts’ Galvin also slapped Citigroup with a US$2 million fine after one of its analysts leaked information to a popular technology blog that was supposed to be private until 40 days after Facebook’s IPO.

The employee was fired.