The US Supreme Court is to rule for the first time in decades on patent protection for computer software, taking up a case that has divided the industry and may reverberate through the US economy.
The justices on Friday agreed to hear arguments on a patented system for limiting the risk that one party to a derivative trade will not follow through on its obligations.
The case splintered a federal appeals court in a ruling that one judge said called hundreds of thousands of patents into question.
On one side of the debate are Google Inc, Facebook Inc and JPMorgan Chase & Co, which say patent standards for software are too lax and open companies to unwarranted lawsuits.
On the other are Microsoft Corp and Oracle Corp, whose trade group told the appeals court that limiting protection for genuine innovation could hurt the nation’s economy.
“This is going to affect virtually every industry,” said Linda Thayer, a patent lawyer with the Finnegan firm in Boston. “Nowadays, we’re in a highly connected, wired Internet world where pretty much everything is implemented by software. Where is the line where there is a true invention?”
The Supreme Court has struggled to decide what types of innovations qualify for patent coverage, generally imposing some limits without drawing categorical lines against legal protection.
In 2010, the justices divided over the rules governing patents for business methods and last year the court limited patents for diagnostic medical tests.
Most recently, in June, the court restricted companies’ ability to patent human genetic sequences.
The Supreme Court has never directly said that software can be patented, although cases in the 1970s and 1980s involved software-related inventions.
The case centers on claims that CLS Bank International infringed patents owned by Alice Corp, a company partially owned by National Australia Bank Ltd.
The software-patenting issue left the 10-member US Court of Appeals for the US Federal Circuit unable to produce a majority opinion.
A majority said aspects of Alice’s patents covering a method of performing the idea were not eligible for protection, while the judges were evenly split regarding systems to implement that idea.
The Supreme Court will hear arguments in March or April next year and rule by July. The case involves the basic question of eligibility for patent protection.
CLS argued that the lower court ruling is consistent with the policy behind the eligibility requirement: “ensuring that a patentee cannot preclude an entire realm of future innovation, while contributing very little to the development of those inventions.”
STEPPING UP: The firm has also asked employees to work in split shifts from this week and to halt all but essential overseas business travel from next month Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) has implemented a remote work policy for employees not on production lines in an attempt to curb the spread of COVID-19, the world’s largest contract chipmaker said yesterday. This is the first time in the Hsinchu-based company’s history that it has launched a large-scale remote work policy, joining global technology companies, such as Apple Inc and Google, that encourage employees to work from home. The chipmaker has also asked employees to work in split shifts from this week, it said. As the number of virus infections continues to climb worldwide, TSMC has urged employees to halt unnecessary
Manufacturers are on a mission to produce desperately needed medical ventilators for the COVID-19 pandemic, even if it means converting assembly lines now making auto parts. Along with a shortage of masks and gloves, the spread of COVID-19 to almost every corner of the globe has highlighted a great need for specialized machines that help keep severely afflicted patients alive. “As the global pandemic evolves, there is unprecedented demand for medical equipment, including ventilators,” GE Healthcare chief executive officer Kieran Murphy said. The group has hired more workers and is making ventilators around the clock. Swedish group Getinge AB is also ramping up output
Facing the rapidly evolving global COVID-19 pandemic, Citibank Taiwan Ltd (台灣花旗) has proactively taken precautionary measures. “The health and safety of our colleagues and their families, as well as our clients and the communities we serve, are of the utmost importance. We continue to take proactive measures to preserve their well-being while we maintain our ability to serve our clients,” Citibank Taiwan chairman Paulus Mok (莫兆鴻) said in a statement yesterday. “We have local and regional contingency plans in place, and we have well-established business continuity plans for the firm. We are monitoring the situation closely, adjusting our operations accordingly,
UPGRADE AND TRANSFORM: Although the cross-strait trade deal might remain, the Ministry of Economic Affairs said businesses should prepare for any disruptions Taiwan might face a decline in foreign trade with China if the cross-strait Economic Cooperation Framework Agreement (ECFA) ends this year, Minister of Economic Affairs Shen Jong-chin (沈榮津) said yesterday. The agreement, which was signed and put into effect in 2010 to reduce trade barriers across the Taiwan Strait, is expected to end this year, despite not having an exact termination date. “We have not received notification [from China] that it wishes to terminate ECFA,” Shen told reporters prior to attending a meeting at the Legislative Yuan. “Even if we are notified, the agreement would only cease after six months.” While acknowledging the