The Chinese Communist Party’s latest “reform” message juggles numerous contradictions with suggestions of significant change, but meaningful action will be needed before history can judge it as transformative, analysts say.
Ending a four-day Central Committee meeting, the party released a communique via state media promising to establish a special “leadership group” on change — but while its makeup will be a key indicator of the party’s direction, no details were provided.
The meeting, known as the Third Plenum, is closely watched because the party has used previous gatherings — most notably in 1978, when it embarked on fundamental economic reforms — to signal seismic changes.
Sometimes, mere semantic alterations can indicate such shifts.
As expected, the party went big on generalities, calling for “comprehensively deepening reform” and letting the market “play a decisive role in allocating resources,” compared with previous terminology that often described its part as “basic.”
At the same time, it reiterated the “core role” of the ruling party, as well as dollops of old-style Marxist jargon pushing the role of the state-owned economy.
It set a deadline of 2020, but only for the achievement of “decisive results in the reform of key areas.”
“It looks like on the direction of reform maybe there is strong agreement, but how to push ahead, maybe not,” London-based Capital Economics China economist Wang Qinwei (王秦偉) said.
Wang said the document appeared to exude “a degree of compromise” and included potential obstacles to change.
Kenneth Lieberthal, a China expert and senior fellow at the Brookings Institution in Washington, said that the communique emphasized balance. Assertions were made and then quickly canceled out lines later.
“In that sense it’s kind of like a US president’s State of the Union address,” he said. “Every key constituency gets a sentence and the fact that they don’t really add up is not important because everybody has a sentence they can point to.”
While details were thin throughout the lengthy statement — widely seen as only a summary with a far longer document expected in coming days — some analysts saw promising morsels.
“We can find some useful implications, such as judiciary reforms and some land reforms from the communique, but the communique may not make this Third Plenum a watershed event,” Bank of America Merrill Lynch economists Lu Ting (陸挺) and Zhi Xiaojia wrote in a report.
They dismissed the rhetoric on the role of the market as a “not so meaningful semantic change.”
“For us Chinese native speakers with years of intensive training in Chinese, we found it very difficult to tell the real difference,” they said.
Key omissions, they said, were any mention of reforms to China’s one-child policy or to its hukou residency system, which denies people who have migrated from the countryside to the cities equal access to benefits.
Nevertheless, some saw the document as largely positive, saying it suggested a level of sophistication that is required to move ahead.
Authorities would need to centralize much of the power to make decisions to push forward economic reforms, ANZ bank economists Liu Li-gang (劉利剛) and Zhou Hao (周浩) wrote in a report.
“Practically, they will also give the markets an important role so that all types of resources can be better allocated for greater efficiency,” they added. “This shows that the new leadership does understand China’s political realities and reform challenges.”
Softbank Group Corp plans to keep a stake in the chip designer Arm Ltd, even if it sells a partial interest to Nvidia Corp, the Nikkei reported. The companies are negotiating terms, the newspaper reported, citing sources. Softbank might take a stake in Nvidia after it buys Arm, the report said. Nvidia and Arm might also merge through a share swap, and Softbank would become a major shareholder in the combined company, it said. The two parties aim to reach a deal in the next few weeks, the sources said, asking not to be identified because the information is private. Nvidia is the
END TO SPECULATION: The hotel’s management contract has been extended, despite reports that it wanted to end its alliance with Hyatt Hotels over a deal with Riant Capital Singapore-based Hong Leong Hotel Development Ltd (豐隆大飯店股份) yesterday said it has extended a management contract to ensure the continued presence of the Grand Hyatt brand in Taipei, ending rumors that the two sides were parting ways. “We are pleased Hyatt is able to come to terms on the extension of the management contract of Grand Hyatt Taipei,” said Kwek Leng Beng (郭令明), executive chairman of City Developments Ltd (城市發展) and Millennium & Copthorne Hotels Ltd (千禧國敦酒店). Hong Leong Hotel Development is a subsidiary of Millennium, and both fall under the Hong Leong Group (豐隆集團). The Grand Hyatt Taipei (台北君悅大飯店), owned and built by
MOVING FROM CHINA? The article did not name the company, but Foxconn, Wistron and Pegatron were among firms chosen for a production-linked incentive plan in India An Apple Inc vendor is looking at shifting six production lines to India from China, which could result in US$5 billion of iPhone exports from the South Asian nation, the Times of India reported, citing people familiar with the matter who it did not identify. The establishment of the facility would create about 55,000 jobs over about a year, the newspaper reported, not naming the Apple vendor. It would also cater to the domestic market and expand operations to include tablets and laptops, the newspaper reported. Samsung Electronics Co and Apple’s assembly partners are among 22 companies that have pledged 110 billion
’WHITE BOX’: The open platform would give local firms access to Cisco’s cloud-based mobile network to develop 5G telecom equipment and tap into the global market The Ministry of Economic Affairs (MOEA) yesterday introduced a new 5G “open lab” in collaboration with US-based information technology and networking giant Cisco Systems Inc to address the rapidly growing “white box” 5G networking equipment market. The open lab will be a platform where Taiwanese manufacturers can access Cisco’s cloud-based mobile network to develop their own 5G telecom equipment, such as small-cell base stations, network switches, modems and Internet of things (IoT) devices, a ministry statement said. The open platform would allow Taiwanese manufacturers to tap into the lucrative 5G telecom equipment market, which was previously monopolized by Nokia Oyj, Ericsson AB